Top 12 College Football Coaches Under Most Pressure to Win
In the high-stakes world of college football, making it to the College Football Playoff (CFP) is a big deal. But honestly, the pressure on coaches doesn’t stop there.
As college football keeps shifting, so do the demands from fans and everyone else watching. Some coaches feel it more than others, and what counts as a “successful” season? That’s a moving target, depending who you ask.
Contents
The Pressure Cooker: Coaches Under the Microscope
For a few coaches, just making the CFP isn’t enough. Fan bases and athletic departments want more—they want wins, and they want them now.
Let’s take a closer look at who’s really feeling the heat this year.
Kalen DeBoer: Alabama’s High Expectations
Imagine going 19-7 in your first two seasons, making the CFP, and still hearing whispers that you’re not the right fit. That’s Kalen DeBoer’s reality at Alabama.
Even with a solid record, rumors floated that he might jump to Penn State if he missed the Playoff. Alabama fans are famously tough, and honestly, DeBoer probably needs at least one big win—maybe knocking off No. 1 Indiana—to get them fully on his side.
Joey McGuire: Texas Tech’s New Era
Texas Tech isn’t satisfied with just showing up in the CFP either. Under Joey McGuire, they’ve poured resources into building a stronger roster, so expectations are sky-high.
He’s delivered by getting the Red Raiders here, but now comes the tricky part—keeping them at this level. A deep run would do wonders for Texas Tech’s reputation.
Coaches with Rising Stock
Not everyone’s under the same microscope. Some coaches have already gone above and beyond, and their fans are mostly just enjoying the ride.
Mike Elko: Texas A&M’s Hope
Mike Elko led Texas A&M to its first-ever CFP appearance. That’s earned him a hefty raise and a contract extension—well deserved, honestly.
A loss to Texas or a Playoff stumble at home might stir up old worries, but for now, optimism rules in College Station. Elko’s stock is definitely on the upswing.
Ryan Day: Ohio State’s Redemption
Ryan Day finally broke his losing streak to Michigan, though Ohio State’s still waiting for another Big Ten title. Last year’s national championship win bought him some breathing room, at least.
A first-round exit wouldn’t thrill anyone, but it probably wouldn’t erase the goodwill he’s built. Still, those four straight losses to Michigan aren’t forgotten just yet.
Steady Progress Amid Challenges
Some coaches are in a spot where just making the CFP helps their case, even if they don’t go all the way.
Brent Venables: Oklahoma’s Visionary
Brent Venables has turned Oklahoma’s defense into a real force, and reaching the CFP has quieted some doubts about where the program is headed.
Even if things go sideways in a rematch with Alabama, he probably keeps the momentum going. But let’s be honest—at Oklahoma, there’s always some pressure to win.
Mario Cristobal: Miami’s Steady Hand
Mario Cristobal has made real progress in four years at Miami. There’s always talk about whether he can win the big one, but a first-round loss to Texas A&M wouldn’t really change the narrative.
Just getting to the CFP is a step forward for the Hurricanes.
Low Expectations, High Rewards
Then you’ve got coaches who aren’t under much pressure at all. For them, any success in the CFP is just icing on the cake.
Jon Sumrall: Tulane’s Underdog Story
Jon Sumrall and Tulane are big underdogs against Ole Miss. Most of the scrutiny on Sumrall is actually coming from Florida fans, since he’s about to take over there.
Still, just getting Tulane to the CFP says a lot about his coaching chops.
John Chesney: UCLA’s Future
John Chesney is set to take over at UCLA, and his current run with the Green Wave has already caught the attention of Bruins fans.
If Tulane loses to Oregon, it won’t hurt his reputation in Westwood. Chesney’s got nothing to lose here, and his stock’s only going up from here.
The High-Stakes World of College Football Coaching
The College Football Playoff is where coaches face their biggest tests. Careers can skyrocket or collapse right here.
Take Kalen DeBoer at Alabama—he’s under a microscope. Then there’s John Chesney at Tulane, who’s got a shot with a lot less on the line.
The CFP really captures the wild mix of pressure and hope that defines college football. Want more on what these coaches are up against? Check out the New York Times article.
