Carson Brumbaugh, SS Santa Fe (OK): Examining the Performance of the Rookie Shortstop in 2024
Carson Brumbaugh represents the new breed of shortstop prospects emerging from the heartland. The Edmond Santa Fe (OK) standout brings a rare combination of defensive skill and offensive power that has scouts flocking to Oklahoma. The two-way talent has established himself as one of the top shortstop prospects in the 2025 class, combining impressive right-handed power at the plate with velocity up to 92 mph on the mound.
The Arkansas Razorbacks commit has been turning heads on the showcase circuit, earning MVP honors at the Perfect Game 16U Mid South Elite tournament. Brumbaugh’s strong, athletic frame and ability to drive the ball to all fields have many evaluators projecting him as a potential early-round selection in the 2025 MLB Draft. His versatility as both a middle infielder with big power and a capable pitcher makes him particularly intriguing to organizations looking for positional flexibility.
| Player Profile | Details |
|---|---|
| Height/Weight | 6’2″ / 195 lbs |
| Bats/Throws | R/R |
| Position | SS/P |
| School | Edmond Santa Fe (OK) |
| College Commitment | Arkansas |
| Velocity | Up to 92 mph |
Contents
Carson Brumbaugh: A Brief Biography
Carson Brumbaugh stands out as one of the top shortstop prospects in the 2025 class, combining impressive physical tools with baseball bloodlines and a commitment to excellence that has put him on the MLB draft radar.
Early Life and Education
Carson Brumbaugh was born on September 20, 2006, in Edmond, Oklahoma. The 6’2″, 195-pound shortstop comes from a baseball family – he’s the son of former MLB player Cliff Brumbaugh and the brother of Cayden Brumbaugh, continuing a strong family tradition in the sport.
He attends Edmond Santa Fe High School in Oklahoma, where he’s developed into a premier two-way talent. His high school career has been marked by steady improvement and increasing national recognition.
Baseball has clearly been central to Carson’s development, with his father’s professional experience likely providing valuable guidance throughout his formative years.
Road to SS Santa Fe
Brumbaugh has established himself as a standout at Edmond Santa Fe, where his versatility has been on full display. He’s not just a shortstop but a true two-way standout who can reach 92 mph on the mound.
| Attribute | Measurement |
|---|---|
| Height | 6’2″ |
| Weight | 195 lbs |
| Bats/Throws | R/R |
| Position | SS/RHP |
His recruitment journey took an interesting turn in 2023. Initially committed to Tennessee, Brumbaugh reopened his recruitment on September 9 and ultimately signed with Arkansas baseball.
Brumbaugh’s profile rose significantly after being named MVP of the PG 16U Mid South Elite tournament. He’s also one of five 2025 prospects selected for Team Oklahoma’s Future Games, placing him firmly among the state’s elite talents.
SS Santa Fe (OK): Team Overview
Santa Fe High School in Edmond, Oklahoma has established itself as a baseball powerhouse with a strong development program for young talent. The team’s reputation continues to grow as they produce high-level prospects like Carson Brumbaugh who have caught the attention of MLB scouts.
Team History
Santa Fe’s baseball program has deep roots in Oklahoma high school athletics, consistently competing at the highest level in the state’s 6A classification. The Wolves have maintained a tradition of excellence under their coaching staff who emphasize fundamentals and player development.
Over the past decade, Santa Fe has produced several collegiate players and professional prospects. Their approach to developing versatile athletes has particularly shown in their middle infield talent pipeline.
The program’s facilities have seen significant upgrades in recent years, providing players with professional-quality training environments. This investment has paid dividends in attracting and developing top talent.
Notable Achievements
Santa Fe’s trophy case includes multiple district championships and deep playoff runs in Oklahoma’s competitive 6A division. The team recently sent shortstop Carson Brumbaugh to the inaugural PBR All-American Game, highlighting their national recognition.
The Wolves’ current roster features multiple Division I commits, including Carson Brumbaugh, Ethan Holliday, and Eli Willits forming perhaps the state’s most formidable infield. Holliday, a legacy baseball name in Oklahoma, brings exceptional defensive skills while Willits provides offensive firepower.
| Player | Position | Bats/Throws | College Commitment | MLB Draft Ranking |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carson Brumbaugh | SS/RHP | R/R | Oklahoma State | #59 Overall |
| Ethan Holliday | 3B | L/R | Oklahoma | Top 100 Prospect |
| Eli Willits | 2B | R/R | Oral Roberts | Unranked |
The team’s participation in prestigious tournaments like Area Code Games has provided valuable exposure for its players against elite competition nationwide.
Carson Brumbaugh’s Career Highlights
Carson Brumbaugh has established himself as one of the top shortstop prospects in the 2025 MLB Draft class. His combination of size, skill, and baseball IQ has turned heads at both the high school and showcase levels.
High School Performance
At Edmond Santa Fe High School in Oklahoma, Brumbaugh has been nothing short of impressive. Standing at 6’2″ and weighing 195 pounds, he possesses the ideal frame for a professional shortstop.
His offensive production has been consistently strong, with a knack for driving the ball to all fields. In a recent game, he doubled to the opposite field to put runners in scoring position for the Wolves.
| Physical Profile | Details |
|---|---|
| Height | 6’2″ |
| Weight | 195 lbs |
| Bats/Throws | R/R |
| Position | SS |
Brumbaugh’s defensive skills match his offensive prowess. His range and arm strength allow him to make plays deep in the hole that few high school shortstops can make.
Awards and Recognitions
Brumbaugh’s trophy case continues to expand with each season. He’s been named to the Perfect Game national rankings, firmly establishing himself as an elite prospect in the 2025 class.
The Oklahoma native has earned All-American honors at multiple showcase events, displaying his skills against the nation’s best competition. Rawlings has recognized his defensive excellence, validating what scouts have been saying about his glove work.
Brumbaugh has committed to Arkansas, joining the Razorbacks’ impressive recruiting class. However, his professional prospects may make that commitment moot.
MLB scouts project Brumbaugh as a potential first-round selection in the 2025 MLB Draft. His combination of present skills and projectability make him one of the most intriguing prep players to watch as the draft approaches.
The Role of Shortstop
The shortstop position demands exceptional defensive skills, baseball IQ, and athletic ability. It’s often considered the most challenging infield position, requiring players who possess a unique combination of range, arm strength, and quick decision-making.
Defensive Responsibilities
Shortstops serve as the anchor of the infield defense. They cover the largest territory of any infielder, patrolling the area between second and third base. This crucial position requires fielding ground balls from both right and left-handed hitters, often hit at high velocities.
The shortstop must execute double plays efficiently, serving as the pivot man on most 4-6-3 double plays. They’re responsible for relay throws from the outfield and backing up third base on throws from the right side of the field.
Carson Brumbaugh has demonstrated an advanced feel for the shortstop position, showing the instincts necessary to excel at these responsibilities. His arm strength allows him to make all necessary throws, a critical trait for shortstops who often need to throw from deep in the hole.
Attributes of an Outstanding Shortstop
Elite shortstops possess a specific set of physical and mental characteristics. Range and quick reactions are paramount – the ability to move laterally in both directions separates average defenders from exceptional ones.
| Key Shortstop Attributes | Brumbaugh’s Profile |
|---|---|
| Height/Weight | 6’2″ / 195 lbs |
| Bats/Throws | R/R |
| Arm Strength | Strong (85 mph across infield) |
| Speed | Average with good instincts |
Arm strength is non-negotiable at shortstop, as Brumbaugh demonstrates with his 85 mph throws across the diamond. His athleticism helps him cover ground effectively, compensating for average raw speed with excellent instincts.
Soft hands, quick transfers, and baseball intelligence round out the toolkit of top shortstops. MLB scouts prize players who can read hitters, position themselves correctly before each pitch, and maintain consistency on routine plays.
Mentorship and Influences
Carson Brumbaugh’s development as a top-tier shortstop prospect has been shaped by key figures who’ve guided his baseball journey. His growth into a five-tool prospect reflects not just natural talent but the impact of influential people in his life.
Influential Coaches
Ty Peeples stands out as a pivotal figure in Brumbaugh’s development. As the head coach at Edmond Santa Fe High School, Peeples has refined Brumbaugh’s defensive mechanics and approach at the plate. Their work together has transformed Carson from a promising young player into a legitimate draft prospect.
The coaching staff with OK Fuel, Brumbaugh’s travel team, deserves credit for his exposure on the national stage. They’ve put him in front of key scouts at showcase events across the country.
Carson’s two-way abilities didn’t develop by accident. His pitching coach at Santa Fe helped him reach 92 mph on the mound, making him valuable both as an infielder and pitcher.
Role Models and Inspiration
Brumbaugh’s brother Cayden serves as his primary role model. The sibling connection has created a competitive but supportive relationship that drives Carson’s development. Many scouts note the similar competitive fire between the Brumbaugh brothers.
Xavier, his hitting instructor, transformed Carson’s approach at the plate. The results speak for themselves—Brumbaugh now displays the big right-handed power that makes scouts drool.
Growing up in Oklahoma, Brumbaugh studied MLB shortstops with similar builds and skills. This research shaped his game as he worked toward his commitment to Arkansas. The Razorbacks commitment shows his trajectory toward potentially being a high MLB draft selection in 2025.
| Player Profile | Details |
|---|---|
| Bats/Throws | R/R |
| Height/Weight | 6’2″/196 lbs |
| College Commitment | Arkansas Razorbacks |
| MLB Draft Projection | Potential early-round pick in 2025 |
Health and Safety in Baseball
Baseball players face unique health challenges that require specific attention to prevent injuries and maintain peak physical condition. For talented prospects like Carson Brumbaugh, staying healthy is crucial to development and future success.
Injury Prevention
Carson Brumbaugh experienced a significant setback when an unfortunate injury derailed his summer. The 6’2″ right-handed shortstop’s development path demonstrates the importance of proper injury prevention protocols.
For infielders like Brumbaugh, shoulder and elbow injuries are particularly concerning. Proper throwing mechanics can’t be overlooked, especially for a player with a strong 55-grade arm.
Proper rest periods are essential. The Arkansas commit benefits from standardized protocols that include:
- Regular assessment of throwing mechanics
- Graduated throwing programs
- Adequate recovery time between high-intensity sessions
- Preventative shoulder and rotator cuff exercises
Medical staff regularly screen prospects like Brumbaugh for early signs of potential issues before they become serious problems requiring hospital visits.
Nutrition and Conditioning
The physical development of Carson Brumbaugh from prospect to draft-ready talent demonstrates excellent conditioning practices. At 196 pounds on his 6’2″ frame, he’s built a physique that supports both his defensive mobility and power potential.
Brumbaugh’s nutritional program likely emphasizes:
| Nutritional Focus | Purpose | Example Foods |
|---|---|---|
| Lean Proteins | Muscle repair | Chicken, fish, beans |
| Complex Carbs | Sustained energy | Whole grains, sweet potatoes |
| Anti-inflammatory foods | Recovery | Berries, leafy greens |
As a two-way standout who can pitch up to 92 mph, Brumbaugh’s conditioning regimen must balance power development with flexibility to prevent contamination injuries that could impact his draft stock.
Historic Players’ Impact on Modern Game
Baseball’s rich tradition shapes how we evaluate today’s prospects. Looking at legends helps us understand what makes a player like Carson Brumbaugh special in the context of baseball history.
Legends of the Sport
The shortstop position has been graced by transcendent talents who forever changed how we evaluate defensive specialists. Derek Jeter’s leadership and clutch performance set a standard that scouts reference today. Cal Ripken Jr. revolutionized the position by proving that shortstops could bring power to the lineup.
Ozzie Smith’s defensive wizardry established the gold standard for fielding excellence. His work at short reminds us that defense at premium positions remains invaluable, something Brumbaugh demonstrates with his advanced hands and feet.
Roberto Clemente’s cannon arm from Pittsburgh’s outfield reminds us that arm strength – a tool Brumbaugh possesses in abundance – can change games instantly. The Pirates legend showed how multi-dimensional players become franchise cornerstones.
Comparative Analysis
When evaluating Brumbaugh, we must consider his physical tools against historical benchmarks. At 6’2″ and 196 pounds, his frame resembles Troy Tulowitzki more than traditional shortstops of earlier eras.
| Player Comparison | Height | Weight | Throws | Bats | Notable Tools |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carson Brumbaugh | 6’2″ | 196 | R | R | Power: 55, Arm: 55 |
| Troy Tulowitzki | 6’3″ | 205 | R | R | Power, Arm Strength |
Brumbaugh’s MVP performance at PG 16U Mid South Elite suggests the kind of trajectory that could lead to early-round draft consideration. His rare combination as a two-way standout with big right-handed power and pitching velocity up to 92 mph mirrors elements of players like Dave Winfield.
Already committed to Arkansas, Brumbaugh’s development path will be closely monitored as the 2025 MLB Draft approaches. His versatility resembles the adaptability that made certain historical players so valuable.
The Business of Baseball
Carson Brumbaugh’s rising status as a top prospect comes with business opportunities that can shape both his career and public persona. From building valuable relationships with brands to managing his image in the media, these aspects will become increasingly important as his draft day approaches.
Sponsorships and Endorsements
The path to potential MLB stardom for Edmond Santa Fe standout Carson Brumbaugh includes financial opportunities well before draft day. As a highly-ranked 2025 prospect, Brumbaugh stands to benefit from the evolving NIL landscape that now allows amateur athletes to monetize their name, image, and likeness.
Local Oklahoma businesses often seek partnerships with top high school talents, particularly those committed to prestigious programs like Arkansas. Equipment manufacturers watch closely, too.
For players of Brumbaugh’s caliber—a two-way talent with power and arm strength—equipment deals for batting gloves, cleats, and training gear represent the most common entry point into endorsements.
| Endorsement Opportunities | Typical Value | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Equipment (Bats/Gloves) | $5K-$15K | Pre-draft |
| Training Facilities | In-kind | Current |
| Local Businesses | $2K-$10K | Post-commitment |
Media Relationships and Public Image
The Arkansas Razorbacks commit has already generated significant media attention, appearing in MLB.com draft coverage more than a year before his eligibility. This early spotlight requires thoughtful image management.
Brumbaugh’s social media presence shows a mature approach—highlighting baseball accomplishments while maintaining a professional tone. This matters to scouts and marketing representatives alike.
His recent commitment switch from Tennessee to Arkansas demonstrates the importance of public communication during key career decisions. How these moments are handled shapes perception among fans, scouts, and future business partners.
For MLB organizations evaluating not just the 6’2″ prospect’s abilities, but also his marketability, these early impressions carry significant weight. The most successful prep-to-pro transitions include strategic media training alongside on-field development.
Carson Brumbaugh’s Future Prospects
Carson Brumbaugh has positioned himself as one of the more intriguing shortstop prospects in the 2025 MLB Draft class. His two-way abilities and physical development have caught the attention of scouts across the country.
Potential in Professional Leagues
Brumbaugh’s professional ceiling appears quite high given his impressive physical tools. Standing at 6-foot-2 and 195 pounds, he brings a rare combination of size and athleticism to the shortstop position. His right-handed power bat projects well at the next level.
What separates Brumbaugh from many peers is his two-way potential. He’s been clocked throwing up to 92 mph on the mound, giving professional organizations multiple developmental pathways.
His frame suggests he could add additional muscle while maintaining the athleticism required for middle infield duties. MLB teams value this body type tremendously.
| Attribute | Details |
|---|---|
| Height | 6’2″ |
| Weight | 195-198 lbs |
| Bats/Throws | R/R |
| Position | SS (Primary) |
| Pitching | Up to 92 mph |
Scouting and Draft Considerations
Brumbaugh currently sits as one of the top shortstop prospects for the 2025 draft class. At the PG 16U Mid South Elite, he demonstrated both offensive and defensive capabilities against top competition. His MVP performance was most notable.
Surprisingly, Brumbaugh remains uncommitted to a college program despite his talent level. This could actually enhance his draft stock, as MLB teams won’t need to factor in signability concerns related to a strong college commitment.
His current trajectory places him firmly on the radar of MLB scouting departments. The Oklahoma native has drawn attention as what one evaluator called “one of the premium performers” in his class.
Draft analysts will watch his senior season closely. Continued development could push him even higher up draft boards. With his physical tools already in place, refinement of his hit tool will be crucial to his final draft position.
